Wednesday, May 31, 2023
Home EP Agriculture and Environment looking for a compromise on livestock emissions

Agriculture and Environment looking for a compromise on livestock emissions

The European Commission insists that something must be done about air and soil pollution from the livestock, poultry and pig industry. A spokesperson for the Commission said the Committee on Agriculture's objections to extending the Industrial Emissions Directive (IED) are much too exaggerated. 

From now on, Brussels wants to include livestock breeding from 150 head of cattle, and tighten the criteria for pig breeding and poultry so that more companies will be included. The European Commission is, however, prepared to make compromises on parts. The Commission denies that there is any question of an imposed regulation: iedereen was allowed to participate in the discussion.

The ENVI Environment Committee of the European Parliament agrees that 'the polluter pays' in these sectors too. The AGRI Agriculture Committee is against the current proposals (as are many EU governments) but the Greens say they will come up with compromise texts in the upcoming trilogue meeting.

In a joint hearing, a spokesman for the European Commission emphasized that livestock farming only concerns the very large livestock farms; at most about fifteen percent. But several MEPs, such as the Dutch CDA member Annie Schreijer-Pierik, pointed out that in some countries with a lot of livestock farming 150 head of cattle is not that big at all.

In addition, virtually all AGRI committee members stumbled over the term 'industrial' in the name of the Directive, as if those three sectors were major industries. The spokesperson for the Commission could only point out that the name of the RIE directive has been around for years and that it now applies to a slightly larger part of the livestock sector. Moreover, the Commission more or less played the ball back by telling MEPs that doing nothing is not a solution.

A frequently heard argument against stricter environmental requirements in agriculture is that the agricultural sector has already reduced a lot of pollution in many areas. The EPP Christian Democrats therefore even think that new environmental requirements should be stopped for the time being. But the Commission points out that nitrate pollution has not been reduced for decades.

The main objective of the RIE (that in a few years' time the industry will be obliged to use the most available modern techniques) has also been met with a lot of criticism. That will be very different for a small pig farmer in Cyprus than for a large pig farm in Germany or Spain, it was noted.

The Dutch SGP member Bert-Jan Ruissen told his colleagues that environmental policy in agriculture might have to be taken on a completely different tack: that the EU no longer prescribes a means, a technique, but a goal. And that the farmer himself – within the law – finds the means to achieve that goal. 'That does mean that we also have to include animal welfare, the environment and climate in the calculations of those goals,' he warned.


EU warns of more cyber attacks on the introduction of 5G

In a risk analysis, the European Union warned of an increasing number of cyber attacks. This mainly concerns attacks that ...

Slightly less air pollution in Europe

Air quality in Europe is improving, but polluted air in particular is causing much damage to the economy and ...

ASML is not allowed to supply high-tech equipment to China and Huawei

The Dutch chip machine manufacturer ASML may temporarily not supply its most advanced machines to China. Previously granted permits to ...

UN warns of the deflation of the countries in southeast Europe

A study by the United Nations says that the countries in the southeast of Europe are confronted with a dramatic drop in population ....

EU on a new front in Libya now also in the pinch between Russians and Turks

Troops from the Libyan military leader Khalifa Haftar are getting closer to the capital Tripoli, thanks to the military support of the ...

Just in

Ukraine threatens WTO complaint against EU import ban

Ukraine has called on the EU countries to end the imposed import blockade of agricultural products to five neighboring EU countries. The scheme runs from 5...

Millions from European crisis fund for climate damage in agriculture and horticulture

Spain, Portugal, France and Italy successfully called on the crisis reserve of the EU agricultural fund in Brussels on Tuesday. Due to climatic...

Spanish rural party gains seats; PP beats PSOE

The new rural party Espana Vaciada ('Empty Spain') won seats in several villages and regional councils on Sunday at local and regional elections in Spain.

Twitter evades EU code of conduct; harbinger of departure ?

The social media platform Twitter, owned by American billionaire Elon Musk, is leaving the European Union's voluntary code of conduct against disinformation on…

Livestock farming also under stricter EU rules against air pollution

The European Parliament's Environment Committee has further weakened the proposal to bring many more livestock farms under stricter RIE emission standards.