Saturday March 6, 2021
Home EU EFSA food: no separate test for Crispr-Cas breeding necessary

EFSA food: no separate test for Crispr-Cas breeding necessary

The European Food Safety Agency (EFSA) believes that no additional EU rules are needed for the use of CRISPR-CAS breeding techniques. In doing so, the EFSA is following an earlier ruling by the European Court of Justice that determined that the current GMO testing criteria for DNA modification in plants are sufficient for CRISPR-CAS.

With this new EFSA advice on CRISP-CAS in plant breeding, published last week, full approval of that technique is a significant step closer. The European Commission had asked for that EFSA advice. Earlier this year, two scientists were awarded the Nobel Prize in Chemistry for their invention of a pair of scissors to perform the CRISPR technique.

With this form of refinement, defective or harmful parts of the DNA can be removed ('cut away') without adding new (different) DNA. According to proponents, this removes the argument of opponents 'that new nature is being created'.

This technique is already used in chemistry and in the development of medicines, but the EU does not yet allow use in the food chain. Experts now conclude that the current safety tests are sufficient: genome editing does not pose any additional dangers.

Gene editing remains a controversial technology, with serious concerns about human health and the environment, according to opponents. The European Parliament has previously stated that the current EFSA testing criteria are not sufficient for current chemical breeding and crop protection, let alone for new DNA techniques.

“With this new advice, EFSA is simply clouding the waters. Contrary to what they claim, gene editing causes dangers that are new and different from conventional breeding, ”warned Luxembourg MEP Tilly Metz (Greens).

The Dutch professor John van der Oost (Wageningen University & Research) previously showed little understanding for the resistance to Crispr-Cas. "Agriculture needs this technology to continue to feed the growing world population," the scientist recently told LTO magazine Nieuwe Oogst.

'Throughout the discussion, far too little attention has been paid to the enormous benefits of gene editing. If we leave everything to nature, we may have to wait a few million years for the right mutation, and we don't have that time. '

WUR chairman Louise Fresco also advocated relaxation of the EU rules for DNA scissors technology. “The Nobel Prize should encourage the EU to lighten the rules for CRISPR-Cas, so that varieties can quickly enter the market that contribute to the European Green Deal and fight hunger. With this, Europe shows that it is working on a socially responsible, sustainable future ”, Fresco told the EU politicians.

Popular

Russian tanks now on Turkish (NATO) south flank

During his visit to the Turkish Foreign Minister Mevlut Casuvoglu, NATO Secretary General Jens Stoltenberg has shown himself very understanding towards the ...

Barnier is also going to negotiate the British EU trade agreement

EU chief negotiator Michel Barnier has been appointed head of the EU team that will negotiate a future free trade agreement with Great Britain. Barnier leads ...

Not all trade union rights also apply at European level

The European Court in Luxembourg ruled negatively on a case brought by the European trade unions against the European ...

CDU hesitates about AKK as the successor of German Chancellor Merkel

The German politician and minister Annegret Kramp-Karrenbauer secured her position as president of the Christian Democratic party CDU last weekend. But...

EU convenes two-year conference on much-needed modernization

The European Commission presented its own ideas on Wednesday for a two-year conference on modernization and reform within the European ...

Just in

In Belgium, too, court has halted construction in agriculture due to nitrogen precipitation

In the Flemish Parliament in Antwerp and in Belgian Agriculture, a lot of discussion has started about the nitrogen problem. After previous ...

German meat tax is not a matter of whether, but how and when….

German LNV Minister Julia Klöckner (CDU) has presented three financing proposals for a multi-billion conversion of German livestock farming. That can be paid by ...

Herds and milk production slightly smaller in most EU countries

In most EU countries, the number of cattle on livestock farms has fallen by more than one and a half percent. New Eurostat data shows that ...

Germans eat much more organic food; opportunities for Dutch exports

Last year, Germans ate almost a quarter more organic food, buying organic food worth nearly 15 billion euros. Germany itself ...

Livestock transport vessel back in Spain; killed hundreds of sick cows

More than 850 possibly bluetongue infected cows that have been on board a ship in the Mediterranean for two months ...