The decision was made last Friday during an informal European summit in Dublin. The five countries that form the core of the delegation are the United Kingdom, Germany, France, Italy, and Poland. This group is known as the E5. They are supplemented by representatives from the European Commission and the European Council. This gives Europe seven negotiators who will participate in talks on ending Russia’s war against Ukraine and future security arrangements.
Anti-Moscow
Notably, the European leaders did not entrust this task to Kallas, who as the EU’s highest foreign representative is precisely responsible for the common foreign and security policy. Her persistent anti-Moscow stance clashes with some EU governments that are cautiously beginning to advocate “that we will have to talk to Putin at some point.”
Kallas’ firm position on some trade issues with China and the US/Israeli war against Iran has been an obstacle in several European capitals. Equally notable is that in recent months EU president Ursula von der Leyen has increasingly involved herself in matters with an international dimension, such as the recent Brussels-backed closer cooperation with Canada.
Anti-Americanism
Von der Leyen and Kallas are not allowed to act independently and must consult European policymakers in advance on politically sensitive issues, or at the very least inform them beforehand. This is more or less enshrined in the EU’s foundation, where international military cooperation has been housed (read: handed over) to NATO since the end of World War II.
The recent cooling of transatlantic relations with the United States is partially fueled by the new American import tariffs unilaterally imposed by President Trump and his increasingly unpredictable military actions (such as threatening to occupy Greenland). This feeds the long-dormant anti-American sentiments in Europe and again leads to calls for a “NATO without the USA.”
(Still?) Not agreed
That in this case Kallas was not delegated by the EU to the US-Russian talks has not only practical reasons (the UK is a NATO member but not an EU member; Poland is a neighboring country of the two warring countries), but also a decisive political reason: the EU countries are (still?) not agreed on a common foreign policy. And so they (still?) cannot speak with one voice.
The Hague debate
This was also the conclusion of the Dutch former Minister of Foreign Trade and Development Cooperation (2021 - 2022) Tom de Bruijn. The former diplomat was also for many years the Dutch ambassador to the EU in Brussels. He participated Tuesday evening in The Hague as a guest speaker in a public talk show organized by the Association for Public Management and the liaison office of the European Parliament in The Hague, together with professor Mendeltje van Keulen from The Hague University of Applied Sciences and Carola van Rijnsoever, the Dutch deputy ambassador to the EU.
New sanctions
The negotiations with the Russians and Americans must focus, among other things, on ending the war, a possible ceasefire, and future security guarantees for Ukraine. The European countries say they want to act jointly, even when representatives from five separate countries directly participate in the international negotiations.
Meanwhile, Kallas remains involved in preparing new European sanctions against Russia. The 22nd sanctions package talks about a possible entry ban for Russians who have participated in the war against Ukraine. According to Kallas, data about these soldiers can be obtained, although questions remain about the practical implementation.