The vote on the transfer tax on agricultural land led to an unprecedented division within Prime Minister Kier Starmer's party. While dozens of Labour MPs abstained from voting, Markus Campbell-Savours chose to vote against the plans.
He stated that otherwise he would break his word to voters and could not face his community honestly. According to him, the tax plans actually affect the farmers he says he stands up for.
Tensions increased further because farming organizations have long warned that the plans could hit family businesses hard. Those concerns closely aligned with Campbell-Savours' argument that especially older farmers without proper transfer arrangements could get into trouble.
Within Labour, the same hesitation was voiced. Dozens of MPs decided not to vote, a remarkably large number for a budget plan. Several Labour representatives indicated that their party risks losing the trust of farmers.
Campbell-Savours himself described his suspension as a painful decision but said he remained committed to his belief that he had to keep his promise to voters. According to those involved, the issue escalated because the tax plans directly affect the future of family businesses. Farmers fear that too high a tax upon transfer means that businesses can no longer remain within the family.
Despite the conflict within the faction, the Labour government continues to support the decision. The tax is intended to contribute to a fair distribution of the tax burden. Opponents argue that this measure actually puts pressure on family-run farming businesses.
The suspension of Campbell-Savours makes clear that the internal discussion within the Labour Party is far from over.